Stateful Architecture vs Stateless Architecture
Best Practices for Developing Microservices
20 System Design Concepts Every Developer Should Know - Part - II
Lets continue our learning journey from Part 1 : Better Engineers is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.
Distributed System Learning Roadmap
Stateful Architecture vs Stateless Architecture
What Is State?
In computing and system design, state refers to the stored information about the status or condition of an application, process, or system at a specific point in time. This information can influence how the system behaves in response to future interactions.
Types of State
Application State: Information managed by the application, such as user preferences, current screen, or shopping cart items.
Session State: Temporary data stored for the duration of a user session, like login status or user-specific settings.
Persistent State: Data that is saved to a database or file system to retain information across sessions or system restarts, such as user profiles or order histories.
Server State: Data stored on the server that tracks the interactions or progress of a client.
Client State: Data stored on the client side (e.g., cookies, localStorage) to manage session or application behavior.
State in System Design
Stateful Systems
Retain state information between requests or interactions.
Example: A user logs into a banking app, and the server retains the session state to allow account transactions without reauthentication.
Stateless Systems
Do not retain any state information between interactions.
Example: A REST API processes each request independently without relying on previously stored information.
Real-World Example of State
Online Shopping Cart
Stateful: The shopping cart remembers items a user adds as they browse, even if the user navigates to different pages.
Stored in session state on the server or cookies on the client.
Stateless: The server would not remember the cart contents. Each interaction would require the client to resend all cart information.
Why State Matters
User Experience: State allows systems to personalize experiences, like remembering a user’s preferences.
System Complexity: Managing state increases system complexity, especially in distributed systems.
Scalability: Stateless systems are easier to scale since no server-specific state needs replication.
Stateful Architecture
In stateful application will have a server that remembers clients' data (that is, their state). All future requests will be routed to the same server using a load balancer with sticky sessions enabled. In this way, the server is always aware of the client.
Stateful architecture involves maintaining the state of user interactions, which is crucial for applications that require user data retention across sessions.
It is important for applications like e-commerce websites where user data, such as shopping carts, needs to be preserved.
The architecture allows for real-time interactions and is beneficial in scenarios where user experience is enhanced by retaining information.
Advantages of Stateful Architecture:
1. Personalized Experience
Stateful architectures maintain information about a user’s previous interactions, enabling the system to provide tailored content, recommendations, or responses.
For example, in an online shopping scenario, the system can remember a user’s past purchases, preferences, or browsing history, allowing it to suggest relevant products or promotions.
This enhances the user experience by making it more relevant and engaging.
2. Seamless Transactions
Stateful architectures are ideal for applications involving multi-step workflows, such as online banking or e-commerce transactions, where session context needs to be preserved across multiple actions.
By storing session data (e.g., items in a shopping cart or stages in a multi-step form), the system can provide continuity in the user experience without requiring users to re-enter information.
This leads to more efficient transactions and a smoother process, especially when the task requires multiple steps or interactions to complete.
Stateless Architecture
A stateless architecture does not store the state information but It simply store state information outside of the server. Therefore, the state of being stateless only applies to the server.
Stateless architecture does not maintain user state between requests, which simplifies the design and scalability of applications.
This approach is often used in microservices, where each service operates independently without retaining user data.
It is suitable for applications that can afford to lose user context between interactions, making it easier to manage and deploy.
Advantages of Stateless Architecture:
1. Scalability
Stateless services do not rely on persistent storage or synchronization across deployment replicas.
This enables seamless scaling, as new instances can be launched independently across a fleet of physical or virtual hosts.
The lack of inter-instance dependencies provides operational flexibility, making it easier to handle fluctuating workloads or sudden spikes in demand.
2. Fault Tolerance
With fewer dependencies, stateless services inherently reduce the risk of failure points in the system.
If a request encounters an issue, the client can retry without requiring any corrective state changes on the server.
This simplifies recovery mechanisms and enhances system reliability, as statelessness minimizes cascading failures.
3. Simpler Debugging and Troubleshooting
The absence of server-side state simplifies problem analysis and resolution.
When issues occur in production, requests can be replayed on development or staging environments to replicate and analyze the sequence of events.
Stateful systems often encounter errors tied to specific server states, which are difficult to reproduce and debug, whereas stateless systems avoid this complexity.
Comparison and Use Cases
The choice between stateful and stateless architecture depends on the specific requirements of the application, such as the need for user data retention versus scalability.
Stateful architecture is often preferred for applications requiring complex user interactions, while stateless architecture is favored for simpler, more scalable solutions.
Understanding these architectures is essential for system design interviews, as they are fundamental concepts in software development.
Last month Refreshers :
If you found this guide helpful and want to stay updated with more insightful posts on software architecture and engineering, be sure to Follow me and Subscribe for more knowledge-packed content. 🔔💻
Happy learning, and may your systems be ever reliable! 🚀✨
Thank you very much for sharing. This is super educating!
Great article!